UNITED STATES COAST GUARD MVI
Washington, D. C. 12 June 1953
(PRINCESS PAT a-11 Bd)
From: Chief, Merchant Vessel Inspection Division
To: Commandant
Via: Chief, Office of Merchant Marine Safety
Subj: Marine Board of Investigation; foundering of the MV
PRINCESS PAT, off Essex Point, Galapagos Island,
29 November 1952, with loss of life
1. Pursuant to the provisions of Title 46 C.F.R. Part 136, the record
of the Marine Board convened to investigate subject casualty, together
with its Findings of Fact, Conclusions, Opinions, and Recommendations,
has been reviewed and is forwarded herewith.
2. The MV PRINCESS PAT, a fishing vessel of 238 g. t., built in 1945,
was engaged in fishing operations in the vicinity of Galapagos Islands.
On 29 November 1952, while en route from the Galapagos Islands for the
Peru Bank, the PRINCESS PAT apparently suffered an undetermined structur-
al failure, took a sudden heavy list and foundered, approximately 40 miles
ESE of Essex Point, off the SW coast of Isabella Island in the Galapagos
group. In abandoning the vessel, one crew member, Andrew Marino, lost
his life. The weather conditions at the time of the casualty were:
a dark night, overcast sky and a calm sea.
3. The Board made the following Findings of Fact:
"1. The MV PRINCESS PAT, official number 248441, of 238 gross
tons, was an uninspected commercial fishing vessel, owned and
operated by Manuel Gonsalves, 2934 Ingelow Street, San Diego,
California. The PRINCESS PAT was built of steel at Newport
Beach, California in 1945 and was equipped with automatic
pilot, fathometer and radiotelephone. The officers on board
the PRINCESS PAT were required to be licensed in compliance
with the Officers' Competancy Enabling Act of 17 July 1939.
"2. On or about 29 September 1952 the MV PRINCESS PAT
departed from San Diego, California, with eight U. S. crew
members aboard and proceeded southward to Puntarenas, Costa
Rica, where five Costa Ricans were added to the crew. From
Puntarenas, Costa Rica the PRINCESS PAT sailed to the Galapagos
Islands for a load of bait. Fishing operations were carried
on in and about the Galapagos Islands and off the Peru Bank
of South America.
"3. The PRINCESS PAT was about half loaded with approximate-
ly 120 tons of tuna aboard on 28 November 1952, the last time
she left the Galapagos Islands, bound for the Peru Bank. At
or about 0100 on 29 November 1952 active navigation of the
vessel was turned over to the following unlicensed crew
members: Mike Valenti of Costa Rica on watch on the bridge
and Andrew Zamberlin on watch in the engine room. At or
about 0430 on 29 November 1952 when approximately 40 miles
ESE of Essex Point, off the SW coast of Isabella Island in
the Galapagos group, the MV PRINCESS PAT assumed a sudden
unexplained 45° list to port causing all hands to wake up.
The vessel began to sink instantly, taking water into the
engine compartment through the open door on the port side.
All hope of saving the vessel was abandoned due to her
sudden erratic behavior and flooding condition. The crew
had no time to don life preservers or to salvage any of
their personal belongings. The vessel's boats were washed
overboard immediately following the severe port list. The
master commanded the crew to jump overboard within one
minute after he was awakened.
"4. It was a dark night with overcast sky and calm sea.
Testimony of the officers and crew revealed that Andrew
Marino, the crew member who was lost, hesitated to jump
overboard at the master's command. It was established
that a few moments after entering the water, several
witnesses heard Marino shout for help. At the time the
master and crew could render only words of encouragement
as each was occupied with saving himself. A few seconds
later, the vessel sank in deep water. It is assumed that
Andrew Marino went down with the PRINCESS PAT.
"5. The master and crew members of the PRINCESS PAT could
merely guess at the cause of the vessel's foundering. No
one claimed to have seen or heard anything unusual aboard
the vessel prior to the severe and sudden list. It was the
stated opinion of the master that a shell plate let go near
the stern on the centerline. This shell plate was renewed
at the National Steel Shipyard, San Diego, in September of
1952, and there was no evidence of faulty welding or of
poor workmanship to support the master's theory of shell
plate failure.
"6. The stability characteristics of the MV PRINCESS PAT,
as established by the inclining booklet and prints of the
vessel, were carefully studied by the members of the Board.
The expert testimony of Mr. Ted Geary, Naval architect who
performed inclining tests on the PRINCESS PAT, offered the
plausible theory that an inboard bulkhead in one of the
large fish wells on the starboard side let go. This would
set into motion a large volume of water, approximately 29
tons. In the opinion of Mr. Geary, this considerable dis-
placement of water, suddenly removed from the starboard side
and flooding the shaft alley, produced a heeling moment that
the vessel could not endure. The PRINCESS PAT's machinery
continued to operate for a short time after she was listed;
but before a radio call for help could be transmitted, the
vessel was going down and had to be abandoned.
"7. The master stated that while swimming away from the
PRINCESS PAT, looking for something to grasp for support,
he swam to a dark object some distance away. This was the
vessel's small skiff. Using the skiff to circle around,
he picked up all the remaining crew members, but could not
find Marino. The search for Marino was continued by all
hands, without success. When daylight came, repairs were
made to the large skiff and the crew rowed for approximately
eleven hours toward Essex Point in the Galapagos Islands.
"8. The crew of four commercial fishing vessels from the
Galapagos Islands provided food and clothing for the crew
of the PRINCESS PAT. The Costa Ricans were put aboard
vessels bound for Costa Rica, while the American crew
members were returned to the United States aboard the fishing
vessel VICTORIA of San Diego."
4. The Board made the following Conclusions:
"1. It is the opinion of this Board that Manuel Gonsalves,
master of the MV PRINCESS PAT, exercised good skill and
judgment in saving the lives of eleven members of his crew,
notwithstanding the loss of Andrew Marino who might have
been saved had he abandoned the vessel upon the command of
the master.
"2. The master of the PRINCESS PAT violated Section 4,
R.S. 4438a (46 USC 224a), by having an unlicensed person
in charge of the navigation of the vessel and by having
an unlicensed person in charge of the watch in the engine
room.
"3. The master and owner of the MC PRINCESS PAT violated
Section 5, R.S. 4438a (46 USC 224a) by engaging unlicensed
persons to navigate the vessel."
5. The Board made the following Recommendations:
"1. Is is recommended that Manuel Gonsalves, License No.
100296, master of the MV PRINCESS PAT, be charged with
negligence for permitting an unlicensed crew member to
navigate the vessel and for allowing an unlicensed crew
member to take charge of the watch in the engine room.
"2. It is recommended that the master and owner of the
MV PRINCESS PAT be cited for violating Section 5 of R.S.
4438a (46 USC 224a).
"3. It is recommended that no further action be taken
and that the case be closed."
6. The Board submitted the following supplemental Opinions and Conclusions:
OPINIONS
"1. That probable failure of the inboard bulkhead of a fish
well on the starboard side spilled approximately 29 tons of
water into the shaft alley, produced a large heeling moment,
and resulted in a 45 degree port list in the MV PRINCESS PAT.
"2. That this port list permitted flooding of the engine
room through an open door on the port side of the main deck,
and allowed progressive flooding of forward compartments
until the PRINCESS PAT filled with water, leveled off, and
sank."
CONCLUSIONS
"2. That had the MC PRINCESS PAT been a Coast Guard
inspected vessel, the frailty of her bulkheads would
have been observed and corrected and this casualty
might have been averted.
"3. That no person or persons aboard the MV PRINCESS
PAT willfully contributed to the foundering of the
vessel."
REMAKKS
7. Contrary to the statement in paragraph 1 of the Board's Findings of Fact, the
PRINCESS PAT, at the time of her foundering, was owned by Otto Kiessig, Manuel
Gonsalves and eight others.
8. Is is recommended that the Findings of Fact, Conclusions, Opinions, and
Recommendations of the Marine Board of Investigation be approved.
/s/ P. A. OVENDEN
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
FIRST ENDORSEMENT TO MVI memorandum of 12 June 1953 M
30 June 1953
From: Chief, Office of Merchant Marine Safety
To: Commandant
Forwarded, recommending approval.
/s/ H. C. SHEPHEARD
APPROVED: July 2, 1953
/s/ MERLIN O'NEILL
Vice Admiral, U. S. Coast Guard
Commandant
The above is re-typed to follow the style of the original document. Assuming the vessel actually foundered about 40 miles ESE of Essex Point, it is unclear why the crew did not attempt to reach Puerto Villamil, or Isla Floreana, distant about 20 and 30 miles, repectively, as shown in the following illutration:
Possibly they were aware that other vessels were in the Essex Point area. In July, 1953, Carl Marino put up a memorial cross at Tagus Cove to honor his brother Andrew, the sole fatality of the incident.
Document Source: http://www.uscg.mil/hq/g-m/moa/boards/princesspat.pdf